4 Comments
User's avatar
Abnerdd's avatar

In response to ‘The Population Bomb’, Julian Simon wrote the much more accurate ‘The Ultimate Resource’. It didn’t get near the media attention of Ehrlich’s book because he believed the human mind (The Ultimate Resource) would solve this problem just like it solved previous domesday scenarios of the past. The authors even held a public bet, with Simon winning quite easily. The bottom line is we will always face large problems as human beings but to bet against their ultimate solutions would be a mistake.

Trevor's avatar

Dear Abnerdd : Welsh by any chance ??

The name Abner means "father of light" or "my father is a lamp" in Hebrew !

Anyway , I noticed that you used domesday , as in Domesday Book (/ˈduːmzdeɪ/ DOOMZ-day; the Middle English spelling of "Doomsday Book") which is a manuscript record of the Great Survey of much of England and parts of Wales historically believed to have been completed in 1086 at the behest of William the Conqueror........which had more to do with valuing land holdings and levying taxes accordingly ......rather than just resources and population......which , to me , was a surprisingly LOW FIGURE of 1.5 to 2 million people !

Judging by the amazing GROWTH since then , they sure "used their imaginations" and increased the resources and wealth exponentially.......it's a pity that the vast majority of that wealth has now been dissipated on 'welfare' rather than further education and innovation !

biologyphenom's avatar

Is this what 'COVID' was really all about? Depopulation?

https://biologyphenom.substack.com/p/scottish-covid-19-inquiryclosing

Also see recent comment House of Commons 11th Sept 2026-MPs debate ‘assisted dying’ bill for the second time in 12 months. https://scotsparlclips.substack.com/p/house-of-commons11-sept-2026-322

Trevor's avatar

Hi Chelsea ! I hope your travels went well !

Yes......these 'over-population-existential-threats' were promoted and promulgated by that

dreadful and inaccurate pessimistic 'forecaster' Dr Paul R. Ehrlich in his doomsday book "The Population Bomb" in which Ehrlich predicted that hundreds of millions of people would starve to death in the 1970s and 1980s. .............Misery , death , doom and disaster seemed to be contagious

and contiguous at that time as another fatuous "Bunch of Experts" were predicting the onset of Global FREEZING ! But , as the same clique now claim ,"There was no scientific consensus in the 1970s that the Earth was headed into an imminent ice age '.......EXCEPT that it KEPT appearing as HEADLINES in all the NEWSPAPERS....strongly supporting all those erstwhile eminently veracious and incorruptible sources of facts and purveyors of truth !!!!!?????? [ 'climatologists !!???' ]

As HISTORY is now only taught in a way that ADVERSELY REFLECTS ON WESTERN CIVILISATION ,

you know the one , the BEST CIVILISATION THAT HAS EVER EXISTED and which MOST PEOPLE NOW enjoy the benefits of while being taught it is terrible [ politely referred to as COGNITIVE DISSONANCE .....but really just A MALEVOLENT AGENDA of LIES and PROPAGANDA ! ] people are unlikely to LEARN of the EVIL effects of Paul R Ehrlich's ANTI-HUMAN views and influence which once adopted by governments worldwide resulted in abortions , killings of unwanted girl-children ,the non-conceptions of many other people and all the ANTI-FAMILY legislation which flowed from him !

The devastating collapse of China's population is directly attributable to adopting his ideology with it's "ONE CHILD POLICY" which officially ran from 1979 to 2015 .

Ehrlich's 1968 book "The Population Bomb ", and the One-Child Policy was heavily inspired by the global "neo-Malthusian" movement that Ehrlich and "The Club of Rome" popularized.

.

Not only that , BUT , HE TAINTED the good name of Paul Ehrlich the genuine and brilliant German Scientist who received the 1908 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his pioneering work on immunity and it was he who devised the term : MAGIC BULLETS where he conceptualized targeted chemical treatments that could seek out specific disease-causing organisms without harming the rest of the body[ and which continues to this day !! ].

The "other bloke" was an ephemeral " sorry excuse of a man" by any comparison !

.

Sadly , many "modern people" have adopted such a miserable materialistic view of their lives , the world and their personal existence in it , that they are either curtailing or limiting their family size

and in THAT WAY fulfilling the dreadful Ehrlich prophecy the "The world population would FALL " !

.

.Cheers Chelsea !